News

Workshop 3: Towards a crop diversification network

At the conference, several actors came together to discuss why a crop diversification network would be important, as well as the challenges, possible objectives, success factors, actors who should be involved, a potential governance structure, tools and next steps.

Why a network?

Crop diversification experiences are diverse by nature because they are tailor-made to local contexts in terms of selected crops, crop diversification strategies, value chain organisation, etc. Therefore, each experience with crop diversification is specific and context-dependent. There is a need to share successful experiences but also to understand which generic lessons can be drawn to be able to successfully implement crop diversification in other contexts.

Barriers to crop diversification exist all along value chains and within sociotechnical systems and they can only be overcome if all actors adapt their practices in a coordinated manner over time. Such adjustments and the urgency to address global challenges require huge steps in terms of exchange and coordination compared to conventional sociotechnical systems and necessitate mobilizing all resources possible.

Challenges

  • Crop diversification concerns the whole supply chains (from farmers to consumers), not only primary production;
  • A global health approach is needed, involving ecosystem, animal and human health
  • Any organizational structure should be appealing enough to set in motion the interest of public players; the research cluster on crop diversification is a good start but not sufficient;
  • Maintaining a network requires time and effort, as well as leadership which cannot be provided by the scientific community alone;
  • It is paramount to go beyond the EU and share experiences with other continents;
  • While the current funding of projects helps initiate joint cluster activities, one needs a funding strategy for longer term networking activities.

Possible objectives

  • Share knowledge and experiences of crop diversification to get inspired (even if experiences cannot be duplicated);
  • Draw generic lessons from local experiences - needs a methodological framework, so research is concerned;
  • Identify barriers at all levels and address them through a co-innovation approach;
  • Link actors along value chains and facilitate matchmaking, both globally and for specific value chains/products;
  • Accompany actors towards diversification with existing crops but, at the same time, support pioneers exploring brand-new crops and developing new uses,
  • Create synergies and develop collaborative projects;
  • Find policy mechanisms that really speed up the process

Success factors

  • Gives motivation to farmers and other actors in the value chain;
  • Develops a sense of identity;
  • Builds on existing networks/groups (e.g., H2020 MAA projects, Operational Groups related to crop diversification)
  • Is built on common objectives (among partners in the cluster);
  • Considers farmers exchange programs (similar to what is done for students with Leonardo, Erasmus +?)
  • Acknowledges that it is a slow process, so it needs time.

Who should be involved?

  • Consumers and citizens to be informed of stakes (clearly distinguishing between the role of consumers and of citizens in this regard).
  • Farmers whose needs are central;
  • Middlemen in value chains as a lot of power resides in the various middlemen;
  • Corporate Social Responsibility and Public Policy are complementary and both necessary when it comes to developing measures fostering crop diversification;

Governance

  • Networks should not rely only on a few individuals; it has to survive if some leave or come in;
  • Members should be convinced of the relevance of tools and goals;
  • It might be useful to structure the network in subnetworks (farmers, scientists, policy, citizens, business)
  • Special attention should be paid to target young generations of farmers.

Tools

  • Consolidate, develop  and open the cluster website;
  • Social networks/Digitalisation of  outputs;
  • Create a “Crop Diversification Gate” (such as ResearchGate, where projects/experiences/data/reports to facilitate interactions and matchmaking,

Next steps:

  • The cluster is going to populate the cluster website in the coming months with outcomes of the conference and results from the different projects;
  • Contacts at the international level to create exchanges have started and will be pursued: the cluster is organising a syposium at the upcoming AAAS2020 conference in Seattle, which will be an opportunity to develop links with North America; contacts with China are ongoing (China Agricultural University).  

A thematic network is being considered to maintain the momentum when projects end (2021 and 2022).

More information

Contacts

  • Dr. Antoine Messean, Coordinator of  DiverIMPACTS, INRA, France, antoine.messean(at)inra.fr
  • Dr. Walter Rossing, Leader of DiverIMPACTS work package 2 „Promoting crop diversification in case studies through actor-oriented research”, Wageningen University, walter.rossing(at)wur.nl

Web links